The “Magic” of the Soother Ooze Tube


KenByrneBy Ken Byrne

Someone once told me that all magic is science, and all science is magic.  To me, a magic show is a series of puzzles for me to solve, trying to figure out just how they pulled off an illusion.  My favorite science demonstrations are much the same.  I love those demonstrations that make me scratch my head and ask, “Why?”

Here is one of my favorites that is easy and inexpensive.  It feels like a magic trick, but it is all science.  It simply involves rolling a cylinder down an inclined plane.  Sometimes the cylinder will roll down quickly.  Other times it will crawl down slowly.

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations Blog

The Soother Ooze Tube Demonstration

Here is what you need:

  • An inclined plane of about 6 degrees (also unscientifically referred to as a ‘ramp’)
  • Some 3 inch rubber bands
  • A 12 x 12 inch square of aluminum foil
  • A Soother Ooze Tube (which you can get right here at Educational Innovations)
  • Some sort of small, regular ball, such as a marble, a tennis ball, a golf ball…
  • A couple of heavy books

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations BlogYou will notice that inside your Soother Ooze Tube is a thick, viscous, liquid.  (The word ‘goo’ is not a very scientific term, but I have found no word that better describes it.)  Before you bring this remarkable cylinder into the classroom, spend some time playing with it.  You will see that it is made to work like an hourglass.  However, instead of sand, it uses that goo.  (See, I told you it was a good word!)

As you turn over your Soother Ooze Tube, the goo will slowly move from top to bottom, passing through the center opening.  It takes about 10 minutes for all the goo to move from one chamber to the other.  You may find it mesmerizing to watch the slow motion drips falling as bubbles slowly rise.

Stand the cylinder upright, like a can of soda.  Once most of the goo has settled in the bottom chamber, it is time to experiment.  Place some heavy books a foot or so from the end of your inclined plane to stop your Soother Ooze Tube from rolling off the table and cracking on the floor.  Wrap a couple of rubber bands around it to act as tires, and then place the cylinder on the inclined plane.  It should roll down the ramp much as you would expect any round object to do… no surprises there.

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations BlogNow, lay your Soother Ooze Tube on its side, horizontally, and wait about five to ten minutes for the goo to settle along one side of the tube.  Once it has mostly settled, try rocking it back and forth on your table.  Notice that it wants to return to the position with the goo at the lowest point.  Move it to the top of your inclined plane and let it go.  At first, it may not look like it is moving at all, but keep watching:  it will be moving, but very slowly.

So why does it do that?

 

Warning: An in-depth discussion of the obvious follows!

Before we discuss this, let’s ask what seems like an obvious question: Why do round things roll downhill in the first place?  We know that they do, but why?

We tend to picture most round objects as having a consistent density.  That is, they are made entirely out of the same solid material.  Other balls, like tennis balls, are hollow, but have a consistent outer shell.  If we took a marble and cut it half, the two pieces, made of solid glass, would have the same mass.  If you cut a tennis ball in half, the two pieces, although hollow shells, would also have the same mass.  In fact, there is no way you could cut these balls in half through the center point and not have the two halves be the same mass.

If you place a ball on a flat and level surface and look at the bottom, you can see that it contacts the table at the center of the bottom of the ball.  With your mind, draw an imaginary line straight up from that contact point and you will see that you have divided it in half.  You have the same amount of ball on one side of your imaginary line as the other side.  It is balanced.  If you turn that ball in any orientation, this is always true…  There is no position that you can turn the ball so it is heavier on one side of that contact point than the other.  The ball has perfect radial symmetry.  As long as it is on a level surface, and it is undisturbed, it will just sit there.

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations Blog

Now place that same ball on your inclined plane and hold it steady.  Take a look at the contact point with the inclined plane.  It is no longer in the center.  If we draw our imaginary line straight up from our contact point, you can see there is more of the ball on the downhill side than the uphill side.  More mass for gravity to act upon means more force pulling on the downhill side of the contact point.  It is NOT balanced.

Again, if you turn the ball in any orientation, there is always more ball on the downhill side of the contact point than the uphill side.  If you release the ball, gravity pulls down with more force on the heavier side than the lighter side, causing it to turn and move down the inclined plane.  As we stated before, this imbalance is true regardless of the orientation of the ball, so as the ball turns, there is always more force on the downhill side and it will continue to cause the ball to turn, rolling down the inclined plane until it reaches the bottom and potentially finds a spot where it is balanced.

(I warned you this was obvious, but had you every really thought about it before?)

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations BlogWhen all the goo has settled at one of the round ends of our Soother Ooze Tube, its mass is evenly distributed across its radial axis, and it behaves like the balls described above.  If placed on the inclined plane, the downhill side will be heavier, and it will roll right down the ramp, like a marble or a tennis ball.

Now, lay your Soother Ooze Tube on a table on its side, horizontally, and wait the five or ten minutes for the goo to settle along one side of the tube.  Place it on the inclined plane.  It should stop, almost (but not quite) motionless.  Look for the contact point, and draw your imaginary line.  Notice that there is still more cylinder on the downhill side, BUT MORE GOO ON THE UPHILL SIDE.

The Soother Ooze Tube has found a position where it is balanced.  The mass of the cylinder plus goo on the uphill side is equal to the mass of the cylinder plus goo on the downhill side.  The force due to gravity is equalized, and the Soother Ooze Tube does not roll.

However, we are not done.  The goo inside is a liquid, and liquids seek their own height.  Looking in your Soother Ooze Tube, you can see that in order to have more goo on the uphill side, it sits higher than it does on the downhill side.

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations Blog

If this was water, it would immediately flow until the liquid was level.  But, our goo is a liquid with a high viscosity.  Chemistry defines viscosity as ‘resistance to flow.’  As our goo slooooowly flows to the downhill side, the downhill side becomes heavier, and it rolls down BUT ONLY UNTIL, ONCE AGAIN, THE SLOW MOVING GOO IS HEAVIER ON THE UPHILL SIDE and it slows to a stop.  But, our goo continues to slowly flow…..  This repeats itself until the Soother Ooze Tube is on a level surface and the goo can level out.

The Magic of the Soother Ooze Tube - Educational Innovations BlogMy favorite way to do this demonstration in the classroom is wrap my Soother Ooze Tube in aluminum foil, completely covering it so the students cannot see the inside.  I then wrap my rubber bands around it for a little traction.  I ask for predictions of what will happen when I place my cylinder on the ramp.

There is always great surprise when the cylinder moves so slowly.  I then casually set it on its end and tell the students to think about it for a few minutes while we work on something else.  I then return to it ten minutes later asking once again for predictions.  Now they all predict that it will move slowly, but instead it speeds down the ramp.  I leave the Soother Ooze Tube sitting horizontally, right where it stopped, and come back to it ten minutes later.  Again, it moves slowly.  It makes a great (and frustrating) thought puzzle for the students.  When I am ready to reveal the secret, I just tear off the aluminum foil.

The Soother Ooze Tube is a great way to introduce many scientific principles in your class.  Use it as a demonstration for:

  • Center of Gravity
  • Fluid Dynamics / Viscosity
  • Force and Motion / Newton’s Laws (F=ma or F=mg)
  • Simple Machines

I hope you find it as enjoyable as I do watching students thinking really hard about something, and enjoying it.  One more bonus:  this demonstration gives you one of the best opportunities to use the word ‘goo’ in your classroom!

 

 

 

 


Discrepant Event Science in the Classroom


Discrepant Event Science! - Educational Innovations BlogBack to School with Discrepant Event Science!

by Mike Matthews

After a restful summer (which included a move to a new school!), classes are finally back in session! I always begin the year with a set of activities that challenge students to practice science process skills (observing, recording data, asking questions, etc.). My approach includes a series of quick “discrepant event” demos that captivate (and baffle) my students. From trying to figure out why two ice cubes melt at dramatically different rates to brainstorming explanations for how a sealed opaque balloon suddenly starts self-inflating, these demos engage students, assess their science skills, and emphasize the processes and habits that scientists use to inquire about the world around them.

Read the rest of this entry »


Top 5 Things You Should Know about NGSS


priscilla-wells-robinsonby Priscilla Robinson

Empowering Performance

The Next Generation Science Standards (NGSS) had a strong presence at the 2016 NSTA Science Conference held this past March in Nashville, Tennessee.  The conference theme was “Empowering Performance” and that’s the foundation upon which the NGSS standards are balanced.  Enthusiastic keynote speeches empowered teachers to help their students “Change the World!”  Educators dashed to workshops and the exhibit hall in search of solutions that will help them understand, implement and survive this rising tide of new science learning standards.  Presently, with 19* states and the District of Columbia already on board with the NGSS adoption, updated standards are making their way into classrooms across the nation.

Read the rest of this entry »


Let Your Classroom Glow with 100 Candles for our National Parks


priscilla-wells-robinsonby Priscilla Robinson

Who doesn’t like to celebrate a big birthday?  As we mark the centennial year of the National Park Service (NPS) on August 25, we as teachers can hook our students’ curiosity with the extensive network of America’s scenic spaces, indigenous wildlife, and natural resources.  If ever there was a year for a solid and diverse learning theme, this is it!  Keep the parties going as teachable moments—this is the best time for teachers to nurture lifelong learners and wards of the Earth.

Read the rest of this entry »


Density in the News


Educational Innovations Newsletter - In the News

Density has been in the news since… well, since Archimedes shouted Eureka.  We have collected a sampling of news stories about density that you may want to use in your classroom as you open a discussion about this fascinating subject.

If you find a news article about density that you’d like to share, please let us know in the comments section.  Happy reading!

Read the rest of this entry »